Uncategorized
How medieval sheep explain why your diary is FULL of meetings

How medieval sheep explain why your diary is FULL of meetings

Ever opened the stationery cupboard to find not a single pen? Or looked at your calendar and realised you’ve been in meetings all day… again… and achieved nothing? This isn’t a modern problem. It’s a centuries-old trap called The Tragedy of the Commons which I see all the time in teams and organisations I work with.

Which just goes to show that the human condition is pretty much eternal.

What is the Tragedy of the Commons?

The way it worked in medieval times was this:

There’s some common land that everyone is allowed to graze their sheep on.  But if anyone can graze their sheep then there is no extra cost to someone in grazing 2,3,4 or even a whole herd of sheep.  The problem is that, if everyone does that, we end up with an overgrazed common and lots of sad, hungry sheep.

When people share a limited resource, and they act in their own self-interest without considering their effect on the others, they can end up depleting the resource, harming everyone in the long run.

Article content
Some sad hungry sheep wish people had made different choices.

How is this playing out in the world right now?

Probably the most pernicious is the use of the commons of time and attention being completely eroded by unrelenting meetings schedules. People put in meetings to further their own goals without remotely considering the impact on the people they are meeting with. The result is having a calendar FULL of meetings. At one point, I was averaging about ten meetings a day.  Sometimes we would have meetings about meetings we were going to have. And then meetings about the fact we were having too many meetings.  This abuse of the commons is rampant within many organisations and it can make it very challenging to actually get any work done.

You’ll see this pattern with any commonly held resource.  Maybe it is the amount of storage people use. Maybe it is pens. Maybe the limited, shared resource is their manager’s attention.  It could also be intangibles like trust, or goodwill.

Some sheep reflect on the self-defeating nature of the this team trap.

My run-in with the Tragedy of the Commons

I worked in a team where every time there was a delivery of pens, people would descend like gannets, take 5, 10, handfuls, whole packets, armfuls (well, ok, maybe not armfuls) of pens and within a few hours there would be no pens for anyone who needed them. And the cupboard would have a fairly desolate air until the next delivery some months later.  If people had just taken one pen at a time, we’d have had enough pens for months.  Eventually the team brought in a limit to the number of pens you could take at any one time, fiercely overseen by the custodian of the stationery cupboard key. It felt a bit extreme to me, I think a sign saying “please only take a couple of pens at a time” might have been a more proportionate response.

How can you escape this trap?

Donella Meadows suggests there are a few possible ways out of this one.

  1. Educate and appeal to people’s better natures: this one can work well. Explain what happens if we all over-use the resource and ask people not to. I had this with an IT team explaining the cost of storing 10 years’ worth of emails and documents and asking that we therefore only kept the documents we really needed to.
  2. Privatise the commons: start charging people for it so people feel the consequences of their actions.
  3. Regulate the commons: this could be through quotas, getting people to apply for permits, agreeing that there won’t be any meetings on Tuesdays or any other mutually agreed approach.

What next?

What’s the ‘commons’ in your workplace that keeps getting drained? Tell me in the comments.

Are your team stuck in this trap now?  If you’d like help spotting and escaping your team’s traps, get in touch.

Follow along this series to discover more team traps and how to escape them. If you missed it, here is article about the first team trap we discussed: Policy Resistance.

And I really recommend Thinking In Systems by Donella Meadows for a fascinating (if quite hard) read on how systems work in ourselves, our teams and the wider world.

Leave a Reply